Willowbrook 51 Years Later: A look at history and modern advocacy - Disability Rights (2024)

January 6, 2023

A 1972 exposé by Geraldo Rivera exposed the revolting conditions at the Willowbrook State School, a facility for youth with intellectual disabilities, in Staten Island, New York. The abuse and neglect revealed by this report led to national outcry, successful legal action, and the establishment of a federally mandated network of legal advocacy agencies protecting the rights of persons with disabilities (the Protection & Advocacy Network). 51 years since the exposé’s release, Protection & Advocacy (P&A) agencies, like Disability Rights Tennessee (DRT), are continuing this critical work of investigating conditions of abuse and neglect, reporting these findings, and advocating for workable solutions.

History of Willowbrook

Willowbrook State School, the largest institution for the treatment of people with disabilities, was opened in 1948, separating this population from the mainstream of society.1 Located in Staten Island, New York the facility was pictured by administration to be a safe institution for residents to receive therapy, opportunities, resources, and proper care. On the contrary, it was understaffed, riddled with disease, and unsafe.

In the mid-1900’s, when institutions like Willowbrook were established, there were very little education or therapy opportunities for children with disabilities and families lacked the resources within their communities to care for a child with disabilities. Families were also encouraged by medical professionals to explore institutional placements like Willowbrook. This guidance, coupled with the lack of community support and resources, made Willowbrook seem like the lesser of two evils. Unfortunately, the reality of living (and working) in these facilities during this time was unimaginable. Residents at Willowbrook had a wide range of disabilities, each requiring individualized interventions and specialized care. However, due to severe understaffing and a lack of funding, residents received a “one size fits all” level of care which was later revealed to be widespread neglect and inhumane treatment. Willowbrook residents, which were mostly children, were left unsupervised for hours at a time without support to meet their basic needs, much less access to care that would allow them to reach their full potential.

The conditions at Willowbrook were appalling. Eventually, physicians employed at the institution began to complain. One physician, William Bronston, referred to Willowbrook as little more than a “human warehouse.”2 Willowbrook State School was a public health crisis, fostering abuse and dehumanization of its residents, while actively deceiving the public. Dr. Michael Wilkins shared with reporter Geraldo Rivera that a staggering 100% of residents at Willowbrook contracted hepatitis within six months,3 and it was so rampant here that researchers took advantage of the situation using residents in medical trials and intentionally exposing them to the deadly virus without their consent.4 The reason many parents were deceived into consent for these medical trials was that participation prioritized a child’s acceptance into the institution, and many felt their children needed to be housed and cared for here.

The Exposé of Willowbrook

Willowbrook State School first caught public attention when Senator Robert Kennedy visited the institution in 1965. He found thousands of residents “living in filth and dirt, their clothing and rags, in rooms less comfortable and cheerful than the cages in which we put animals in the zoo.”2 This event, along with journal articles by reporter Jane Kurtin, put Willowbrook in the spotlight prompting the New York State Government to develop a five-year plan for improvement. However, State officials were indifferent to how these residents were being treated, due to an individual with disabilities being “devalued by society” at this time.2 As this was a “total institution,” conditions quickly returned to being unsafe.

Following the failed attempts to expose the horrors at this facility by journalists and staff, investigative reporter Geraldo Rivera released the monumental firsthand investigation and exposé Willowbrook: The Last Disgrace in 1972, catching the public’s attention internationally. This exposé was made possible by two of Willowbrook’s physicians: William Bronston and Michael Wilkins. They reached out to Rivera and brought him onto the grounds to film, allowing him entrance to building six. This moment would become revolutionary for the disability community, the residents in this facility, and Geraldo himself as he captured the abhorrent conditions within.

Rivera’s visit to the unit was unannounced, allowing for a true observation of the setting, without the administration’s ability to prepare. Rivera recalled the experience of this raw moment, stating that “the doctor warned me it would be bad; it was horrible… how can I tell you about the way it smelled? It smelled of filth, it smelled of disease, and it smelled of death.”

Rivera and his team witnessed what they describe to be some of the most unspeakable things they had ever seen in their life. Children were grouped together on the floor, covered in their own feces with one attendant responsible for managing the care of 50+ residents. They were left to sit alone, without social interaction or access to necessary education or treatment. The video documenting this visit shocked the American public, inspiring action and change for the disability community.

Resulting Legislation

Disturbed by the conditions of their children, the parents of Willowbrook residents filed a class action suit alleging that conditions at Willowbrook violated the constitutional rights of residents including the failure to provide habilitation for residents, lack of privacy, and inadequate medical facilities.2 In summary, these residents had a constitutional right to be free from harm within this facility. A U.S. District Court Judge went on to sign the Willowbrook Consent Judgment which set guidelines and requirements for the institution’s operation, and established standards of care for all Willowbrook residents at the time of the settlement. This Consent Judgement has had lasting effects that we can see even today, 51 years later.

Political reaction to this case led to the enactment of more legislation such as the Protection and Advocacy (P&A) system in the Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act, the Education for all Handicapped Children Act, and the Civil Rights of Institutionalized Persons Act (CIRPA).2 The Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act and CIRPA were the first federal civil rights laws that protected people with disabilities, eventually leading to the enactment of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).2 These Acts paved the way for advocacy today, and their legacies live on even if the laws themselves have changed. They laid a foundation for the needs and rights of individuals with disabilities to be respected and prioritized within care facilities.

Institutions Today

As a result of historic legislation protecting the rights of persons with disabilities, Protection & Advocacy agencies were created to ensure people with disabilities are treated equally. As the Protection & Advocacy (P&A) agency for the state of Tennessee, Disability Rights Tennessee works daily to protect and expand the rights for people with disabilities across the state. Through individual and systemic advocacy, DRT ensures Tennesseans with disabilities are free from harm, have access to appropriate treatment, are empowered, and are included in their community. Although the respect for the rights of all persons has made advancements, there is still a critical need for protection and advocacy. Willowbrook: The Last Disgrace set a foundation for agencies like DRT to be present within facilities, monitoring and advocating for those within.

Last year DRT released two reports on this topic after observing facilities in Tennessee under the supervision of the Department of Children’s Services (DCS). These reports have demanded public attention and served as a catalyst for change, just as Rivera’s Willowbrook exposé did 51 years ago. In April 2022, Disability Rights Tennessee (DRT) released a report with Youth Law Center (YLC) titled Designed to Fail. After receiving numerous reports of educational neglect and the use of aversive behavior modifications like solitary confinement and restraint, DRT conducted an 18-month investigation into Wilder Youth Development Center, a facility run by the Tennessee Department of Children’s Services in West Tennessee. The release of this report in early 2022 was a catalyst for significant changes within the facility and prompted the creation of a legislative and oversight committee for TN’s Juvenile Justice practices. Read this report or the executive summary here. In December, DRT and YLC released another report on DCS, Families not Facilities. This report includes additional findings and focuses on a series of recommendations, solutions and steps that need to be taken to improve the situation for children, families and youth trapped in the systems of DCS and the greater youth justice system. Read this report here.

Willowbrook: The Last Disgrace was the stimulus for lasting change in the disability rights world. The bravery of those advocating for its residents resulted in lasting change, still seen today. Although we have made a lot of progress in recognizing the rights of individuals with disabilities, issues are still present. Just as an example, isolation and restraints were improperly used in the mid 1900’s and are still used in this manner today. The work done by P&A agencies nationally is important, as most people will have or know someone with a disability. Disability Rights Tennessee is proud to be a Protection & Advocacy agency in a network established by groundbreaking legislation resulting from the Willowbrook exposé. If you or someone you know is experiencing abuse or neglect in any facility, contact DRT at 800-342-1660 or GetHelp@DisabilityRightsTN.org.

Resources

  1. https://www.csi.cuny.edu/about-csi/president-leadership/administration/office-vp-economic-development-continuing-studies-and-government-relations/reporting-units-and-initiatives/willowbrook-mile/about
  2. https://disabilityjustice.org/the-closing-of-willowbrook
  3. https://mn.gov/mnddc/parallels/five/5f/willowbrook.html#:~:text=100%25%20of%20patients%20at%20Willowbrook,Who’s%20in%20charge%20here%2C%20Jerry%3F
  4. https://bioethicsresearch.org/resources/case-studies/hepatitis-studies-at-the-willowbrook-state-school-for-children/#:~:text=Case%3A%20Hepatitis%20studies%20were%20conducted,that%20children%20would%20contract%20Hepatitis.
Willowbrook 51 Years Later: A look at history and modern advocacy - Disability Rights (2024)

FAQs

What rights were violated in the Willowbrook study? ›

Disturbed by the conditions of their children, the parents of Willowbrook residents filed a class action suit alleging that conditions at Willowbrook violated the constitutional rights of residents including the failure to provide habilitation for residents, lack of privacy, and inadequate medical facilities.

What laws were passed after Willowbrook? ›

The political reaction to this case led to the enactment of legislation such as: The Protection and Advocacy (P&A) System in the Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act (1975); The Education For All Handicapped Children Act, P.L. 94-142 (1975); and.

What was the Willowbrook scandal 50 years ago? ›

At the Willowbrook State School in Staten Island, children and adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities were beaten, experimented on, and left to suffer in deplorable, overcrowded, understaffed, and squalid conditions.

What was Willowbrook State School and explain why it was controversial? ›

The school was designed for 4,000, but by 1965 it had a population of 6,000. At the time, it was the biggest state-run institution for people with mental disabilities in the United States. Conditions and questionable medical practices and experiments prompted US Senator Robert F. Kennedy to call it a "snake pit".

What rights and services were the Willowbrook residents entitled to? ›

If the consumer is a resident of the Richmond Complex on Staten Island, the consumer has the right to high quality and appropriate medical and habilitative services, shelter, food and clothing which at a minimum conforms to state and federal regulations.

What was the Willowbrook experiment summary? ›

Willowbrook Studies & Results

The studies began in the 1950s and lasted for 15 years. Children aged 3 to 10 being housed at Willowbrook were the subjects of the study. Dr. Krugman noticed that students who were infected with hepatitis recovered, and then appeared to be immune to future outbreaks of the disease.

Is The Lost Girls of Willowbrook a true story? ›

Based on a true story, it follows what happens to Sage Winters when she travels to Willowbrook to help find her twin sister, Rosemary, whom she believes had died of pneumonia six years earlier, but discovers was left at Willowbrook School by her mother and stepfather because her behavior was unmanageable.

How many Willowbrook class members are still alive? ›

They became homeless on the streets of New York, and many actually came back to inhabit the abandoned buildings that were their homes for most of their lives. There are about 2,300 Willowbrook survivors alive today.

Does Willowbrook still exist? ›

The remaining 171 acres of the Willowbrook property at the south end, is still under the administration of the New York State Department of Mental Health, which maintains a facility there called the Institute of Basic Research in Developmental Disabilities.

How many Willowbrook survivors are still alive today? ›

The New York Times' investigation found that “Many of the institution's 2,300 alumni who are alive today still suffer from mistreatment" (Weiser).

What happened to the children at Willowbrook? ›

Many who came to Willowbrook lived a short, brutal existence. They died because of neglect, violence, lack of nutrition, and medical mismanagement or experimentation. Some simply disappeared or even committed suicide.

Who exposed Willowbrook? ›

We look back at journalist Geraldo Rivera's 1972 landmark investigation of Staten Island's Willowbrook State School, an institution for the developmentally disabled. His expose forever changed the face of mental health.

What are the ethical issues of Willowbrook? ›

The issues include : the vulnerability of the test subjects, interference with informed consent and the non-therapeutic nature of their experiment for their subjects.

Why did Geraldo Rivera expose Willowbrook? ›

The film, with then Eyewitness News reporter Geraldo Rivera, was one of the first exposes on local television. Rivera broke the stories, after doctors, disgusted by what they were seeing at Willowbrook, let him in -- to tell the world what was really going on behind closed doors.

What is the story behind Willowbrook? ›

Willowbrook State School was a state-supported institution for children with intellectual disabilities. Designed to accommodate 4,000 children, by 1965 Willowbrook had a population of 6,000, and scandal soon erupted over news of the institution's horrendous conditions and questionable medical practices.

What was unethical about the Willowbrook experiment? ›

The issues include : the vulnerability of the test subjects, interference with informed consent and the non-therapeutic nature of their experiment for their subjects.

Which right was violated in the Willowbrook Hospital study in which children were deliberately infected with hepatitis? ›

Every physician takes an oath to first do no harm. Dr. Krugman violated this with his treatment of intellectually disabled children at Willowbrook State School. Other issues regarding the Willowbrook Study were the methods of informed consent.

Which action occurred at the Willowbrook State School that was identified as being unethical scientific research? ›

The Willowbrook Hepatitis Experiments involved intentionally infecting mentally disabled children with the hepatitis virus to study the progression of the disease.

What happened to the children of Willowbrook? ›

An estimated 12,000 residents died at Willowbrook from 1950-1980, approximately 400 a year. Many who came to Willowbrook lived a short, brutal existence. They died because of neglect, violence, lack of nutrition, and medical mismanagement or experimentation. Some simply disappeared or even committed suicide.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Carmelo Roob

Last Updated:

Views: 5315

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carmelo Roob

Birthday: 1995-01-09

Address: Apt. 915 481 Sipes Cliff, New Gonzalobury, CO 80176

Phone: +6773780339780

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Gaming, Jogging, Rugby, Video gaming, Handball, Ice skating, Web surfing

Introduction: My name is Carmelo Roob, I am a modern, handsome, delightful, comfortable, attractive, vast, good person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.